Weekly Natural Gas Storage Survey
North America's Biggest Weekly Natural Gas Storage Survey and Forecast
 
Energy Metro Desk Storage Survey Average: +53.8Bcf  
Energy Metro Desk Storage Survey Median:  +53Bcf  
EMD Survey High: +60Bcf
EMD Survey Low: +46Bcf 
EMD Standard Deviation: 3.2
EMD 
Std. Deviation Previous 4 Weeks: 
3.2 (9/2) 2.9 (8/26) 3.5 (8/19); 2.8 (8/12)
 
for report date
9-2-2010
 
                 ***
Energy Metro Desk 
Editor's Forecast: +58 Bcf  
                   ***
The Game:
Each week we poll between 30-36 professional storage forecasts for our weekly Natural Gas Storage Boxscores (as seen in each bi-weekly issue of Energy Metro Desk*). This is North America's biggest natural gas storage survey.
 
We separate each forecast into three distinct categories:
1. Major Surveys (up to 7) 
2. Bank Analysts (up to 10)
3. Independent Analysts/Models/Non-financial Firms (up to 19) 
 
This week, the preliminary tallies (36 estimates reported) are:  
 
**Survey's Polled This Week: 7
Survey's Forecast Avg: +53.68 Bcf
**Bank Analysts Polled: 10
Bank Analyst Forecast Avg: +55 Bcf
**Independents Polled: 19
Ind Analyst Forecast Avg: +53.21 Bcf
_________________________________ 
This week, RISK is slightly to the UPSIDE. Most analysts who responded to our question about whether they foresee upside or downside risk this week (not all 36 analysts regularly respond to our additional question about upside/downside risk) said that their forecast had risk to the UPSIDE. These analysts had a range of forecasts between 50-56 Bcf. 
_________________________________
10th Percentile (bottom 10%) @ +50Bcf 
25th Percentile (bottom 25%) @ +52Bcf
75th Percentile (Top 25%)  @ +55.3 Bcf
90th Percentile (Top 10%) @ +58.5 Bcf
 
'09 EIA Report Number: +64 Bcf
'08 EIA Report Number: + 90 Bcf 
5-yr avg: +59 Bcf 
3-yr avg: +60 Bcf   
5-yr Hi-Lo: 102 & 43 Bcf
                         *** 
Total Storage as of Last Week: 3,052 Bcf
Year on Year Surplus: -198Bcf
Surplus Over 5 Yr Average: +177 Bcf 
                           ***
 This week's HiBallers
David Tameron, Wells Fargo/60 Bcf; Marshall Adkins, Raymond James/60 Bcf; Paul Belflower, Mustang Fuel/59 Bcf; EMD Editor/58 Bcf; Gene McGillian, TFS/57 Bcf; Cameron Horwitz, SunTrust/56 Bcf.
 
This week's LowBallers: 
Het Shah, Motion Capital/46 Bcf; Pat Wong/49 Bcf; Stu Young, Morgan Stanley/50 Bcf; Peter marrin/SNL Editor/50 Bcf; Luke Larson, Fundamentalist/50 Bcf; PIRA/50 Bcf.
 
                          ***
1st Early View For Next Week:
EMD: +60-68 Bcf 
Others: +50-65 Bcf 
Last Year: 68 Bcf 
5-Year Avg: 61 Bcf                
 
          ***
HDDs Last Week: 3
HDDs Last Year:  5
CDDs Last Week: 64
CDDs Last Year:  59
CDDs 5 Year Avg: 58  
                  ***
Past 4 weeks' tally: 133 Bcf (33Bcf/wk)
2009, same period: 237 Bcf (59.25/week)
5-yr average, same period: 195 (48.75/wk) 
 
                           ***
 

Binary Storage Swap Indications for 9/2 (report date 9/2 for week ending 8/27).

52/55 Bcf  (Courtesy of TFS/Tradition)

                            ***

Power production in the lower 48 states for the week ended Aug. 28 rose 3.2 percent from the same week in 2009 to 85,804 gigawatt hours, according to EEI. New England showed the largest year-on-year percent decline in output: 9.7 percent to 2,495 GWh. For the first 35 weeks of the year, power production came in at 2,777,103 GWh, up 4.3 percent from last year.
                          ***  
Only paid subscribers to our bi-weekly Energy Metro Desk publication may view the full listing of all 36 (+-) analysts and models and surveys polled for our weekly storage survey. 
 
Subscribe today by calling 410/923-0688.
                              ***
  Hey, Read This!

Third Annual Risk Management in Energy Trading Conference

Evolving Risk Management Practices to Comply With Key Regulatory Reforms and Meet Changing Market Demands October 21-22, 2010 in Houston, TX

marcus evans invites C-Level Executives, SVPs, VPs, Directors, Head and other Senior Executives in Risk Management, Risk Analysis, Middle Office, Market Risk, Credit Risk, Commodity Risk and Commodities Trading to attend this premier conference.

For a Full List of Speakers and Conference Topics click here. For more information or to receive a 10% discount on this conference, please email Michelew@marcusevans.com

Our Tealeaves:

 

Last weeks's 40 Bcf build was a sliver away from "right on the money." The three categories we track -- surveys, bank analysts and independant analysts -- all came in around 2 Bcf shy of the print. Three people (out of 35): Donnie Sharp of Huntsville Utils, Kyle Cooper of IAF Advisors and Luke Larson of The Fundamentalist were spot on at 40 Bcf. The editor said 42 Bcf and the Metro Desk Consensus was 38.7 Bcf. We noted last week's Early Views averaged 51.46 for this week's report; most of those early views later increased by roughly 3 Bcf by end of day Tuesday (8/31). Analysts said risk was to the upside this week. For the 9/2 report, the editor's expectation is close to the high end of the range at 58 Bcf. The Metro Desk Consensus is at 53.8 Bcf.

 

                         ***

 

"When forecasting this week's estimate, we looked to data from last year. Our y/y comp is an injection of 61 Bcf. Given the continued extreme heat last week, the market was 0.57 Bcf/d tighter last week. We expect the market to continue to run flat on a y/y basis for the week. Our official forecast for this Thursday is for an injection of 60 Bcf. If our forecast is right, the year-over-year storage deficit of 198 Bcf will increase by 4 to a deficit of 202 Bcf, according to a research note from Marshall Adkins' crew at Raymond James.

                             ***

New member of the Weekly Boxscores, Cameron Horwitz of SunTrust Robinson Humphrey is calling a highish 56 Bcf build for the week. "The higher w/w injection is largely a function of a 3 Bcfp/d w/w decline in gas-fired power generation as cooling degree days fell 14 percent on a sequential basis.  LNG send out remains anemic, coming in at less than 0.8 Bcfp/d this week," he says. "With warmer-than-normal temps expected this week and next, we have adjusted downward our Nov 1st storage estimate to 3.65 Tcf," Horwitz says.                     ***

Ron Denhardt of SEER (at 55 Bcf this week) was not impressed by the latest release of EIA's 914 data. Actually, nobody was all that impressed with the 914 stuff; most folks we spoke to are expecting a revision next time. "As indicated yesterday, the EIA 914 data showing that gross withdrawals fell 1.7% from May to June has increased our concern about the quality of (EIA) data. Data from Lippman Consulting Inc. and Bentek showed growth of .2% to .7%. Over the last six months the average monthly growth rates from the three sources range from .6% to .8% (7.4% to 9.6% per year). During the last three months, the EIA has shown a net decline in production while Bentek and LCI both show about .5% per month growth. All but about .1 Bcf/d of the EIA reported decline was because of unusual circumstances (.30 Bcf/day was lost because of Hurricane Alex and pipeline problems and Wyoming declined 0.38 Bcf/day because of plant problems. However, there are always unusual circumstances. In May .18 Bcf/d of production was lost in the Gulf offshore because of pipeline repair and .4 Bcf/d was lost in Wyoming because of repairs." AS for this week, Denhardt notes that LNG imports averaged .8 Bcf/d for the week and the average US/UK prompt month arb stood at $(2.00)/MMBtu (US prices below UK). Also, nuclear capacity utilization averaged 96.1% vs. 94.1% last week and 95.7% a year ago.

                          ***

The good folks at UBS are also expecting a seasonally low 55 Bcf build this week, largely due to the continued hot weather last week. "We estimate inventories rose to 3,107 Bcf, widening the deficit vs. 2009 to 216 Bcf and narrowing the surplus vs. the 5-year average to 143 Bcf. Last week, weather was 22% and 9% warmer than 2009 and the 5-year average, respectively. Since May, weather has been 24% and 16% warmer than last year and the 5-year average, respectively. The storage refill season has ~24% of CDDs remaining." Also, UBS says that the weather-adjusted S/D balance loosened ~0.5 Bcf/d in the week ending August 20th, but has been balanced over the last month vs. the 5-yr average but ~0.5 Bcf/d oversupplied vs. last year. We believe natural gas prices need to fall to moderate drilling activity and reduce the rate of domestic production growth (which we estimate was 3% in 2Q but are trending toward 8% YoY in 4Q). We forecast the injection season to end at 3.75 Tcf on 10/31, 0.25 Tcf above normal. "

                              ***

BENTEK projects the East Region will inject 55 Bcf this week. The total regional working gas volume in storage is now at 1,679 Bcf. This level is 1.2% above the five-year average and 5.1% below the five-year high. During the same week last year, there was a 51-Bcf net injection into storage fields in the East Region. BENTEK projects the Producing Region will have a net injection of 8 Bcf this week. The total regional volume in storage is now at 957 Bcf. This level is 9.6% above the five-year average and 11.8% below the five-year high. During the same week last year, the Producing Region posted an injection of 7 Bcf. BENTEK projects the West Region will withdraw 9 Bcf this week, bringing the total regional volume to 470 Bcf. This level is 16.0% above the five-year average and 2.2% above the five-year high. During the same week last year the region injected 6 Bcf.

                          ***

Sriram Vasudevan of Macquarie Energy in NYC is at 51 Bcf for the week. "Though many folks are leaning to the mid-50s, I am not. While weather was definitely much milder on a sequential basis my weather normalized Nat gas power burns did quite well even with milder weather-basically we are continuing to get good "demand purchase" for gas-fired plants at "sub-coal prices" in many parts of the country." He says further that even though his domestic supply scrapes showed a good surge, the Canadian "net imports" are showing a sharp y-o-y decline.  While Imports from Canada did not show much of a surprise the "Re-Exports to Ontario" from St. Claire MI was quite strong on both GLGT (almost 40% y-o-y increase) and to a lesser degree on Vector.  "Thus my S&D residual keeps me at a moderate + 51 BCF storage build for the week." Currently, his end-of-summer paths are below 3.67 Tcf (with No Hurricane adjustment). Winter paths still point to more than adequate stocks (mean of 1.65 TCF and mild winter {-1 sigma} at 1.8 TCF on higher residual) for end of winter 2010/11."

                              
 From Last Year's EMD/Same Week:
 
 "For the September 3, 2009 report, we had two winners, one human. Though the Dow Jones survey nailed the reported 65 Bcf build, Gene McGillian of TFS was the lone carbon-based lifeform to nail it too. So, for September 3, Gene McGillian of TFS is the Best Natural Gas Storage Forecaster in the Land, beating 30 others. Twenty-five of 30 forecasts came within 5 Bcf of the EIA number, and all but one - Bill Featherston of UBS called a 80 Bcf build - came within 10 Bcf of the EIA re-port. For the Sept. 3 report, the surveys came in second at 64.76 Bcf. The winning category for the week was the bank analysts, who took the prize with a razor thin margin of 65.12 Bcf. Independent analysts pulled a third with an average forecast of 64.14. The Desk Consensus came in at 64.6 Bcf. The editor's forecast came in at 70 Bcf. The LowBaller of the week at 56 Bcf was the Bentek Flow Model and the Highballer was UBS at 80 Bcf."

 

 

                                  Courtesy of CME DataMine. Click Here for More Info  
 
cme for 8-26
From Last Year's EIA Report (9/3/09) Working gas in storage increased to 3,323 Bcf as of Friday, August 28, 2009, according to EIA's Weekly Natural Gas Storage Report. The implied net injection of 65 Bcf was 1.6 percent above the 5-year average (2004-2008) net injection of 64 Bcf, but about 29 percent below last year's net injection of 92 Bcf for the same report week. Current levels of working gas in storage remain significantly above both the historical levels, with current stocks exceeding the 5-year average by 17.8 percent and last year's levels by 17.3 percent. The latest report indicates that the volumes of natural gas in storage continue to outpace historical levels. With 9 weeks remaining in the current injection season, current working gas in storage is only 242 Bcf shy of the all-time high of 3,565 Bcf reached at the end of October 2007. At 3,323 Bcf, current storage is only 76 Bcf lower than the available gas in storage at the beginning of last year's heating season.

Metro Desk Express is a weekly natural gas storage forecasting tool. The publication features the country's biggest natural gas storage survey and lots of really great data and analysis. A one year subscription is $499/50 weekly issues -- less than $10 a week? No kiddin'.

If you would like to subscribe to this weekly service call us at 410/923-0688 or for more information, email your subscription inquiries to subscriptions@scudderpublishing.com.
 
 

Scudder Publishing Group LLC 
 www.scudderpublishing.com
editor: 
johns@scudderpublishing.com
410.923.0688 
1145 Generals Hwy  Crownsville, Maryland 21032